How Do I Decide Between Pricing Slightly Under Market Value Versus Pricing at the Top of the Range?

One of the hardest pricing decisions sellers face is whether to price a home slightly under market value to attract attention or at the top of the range to maximize return. On Long Island, the right choice depends less on preference and more on buyer behavior, competition, and timing.

What “Under Market” and “Top of the Range” Really Mean

These strategies are often misunderstood.

• Pricing slightly under market value means positioning the home at a level that attracts the widest pool of qualified buyers.

• Pricing at the top of the range means aiming for the highest price buyers have recently paid for similar homes — assuming strong demand supports it.

Neither approach is inherently right or wrong. The effectiveness depends on how buyers are currently responding to similar listings.

When Pricing Slightly Under Market Value Makes Sense

This strategy can work well when the goal is to generate early interest.

It’s often effective when:

• Buyer demand is strong

• Inventory is limited

• Your home shows well compared to competing listings

• You want to encourage multiple buyers to engage quickly

More activity early can sometimes create competitive pressure, which helps protect negotiating leverage.

When Pricing at the Top of the Range Is More Appropriate

Pricing at the higher end of the range can make sense when conditions support it.

This approach may work when:

• Comparable homes are selling quickly

• There’s limited competition in your price bracket

• Your home offers features buyers strongly value

• Buyer demand is steady and predictable

In these cases, buyers may be willing to pay a premium if the home clearly stands out.

The Risks of Each Strategy

Every pricing approach carries trade-offs.

Pricing under market can:

• Create urgency, but

• Attract buyers with lower expectations if not positioned carefully

Pricing at the top of the range can:

• Maximize return if demand supports it, but

• Reduce showings if buyers feel pricing is stretched

The key risk in both cases is misalignment with current buyer behavior.

How Buyer Psychology Influences Pricing Outcomes

Buyers often compare homes based on perceived value, not just price.

Factors that shape perception include:

• How your home compares to active listings

• Monthly payment differences

• Condition and layout

• How long similar homes have been sitting on the market

Understanding buyer psychology helps determine whether a slightly lower price creates momentum or whether buyers are already comfortable paying at the top of the range.

Making the Decision With Confidence

The goal isn’t to guess — it’s to position your home where buyers are most likely to act.

A thoughtful pricing decision weighs:

• Recent sales for context

• Current competition

• Buyer demand and affordability

• How quickly you want or need to sell

This decision often connects to related questions like “Should I accept the first offer?” or “What happens if my home isn’t getting showings?”

FAQs

Is pricing under market value a risky strategy for sellers?
It can be effective when demand is strong, but it needs to be done strategically. Understanding whether it fits your situation is easier with guidance — you can explore that here: 👉 https://www.theericbermanteam.com/contact-us

Will pricing at the top of the range scare buyers away?
It can if demand doesn’t support it. Evaluating current buyer behavior helps reduce that risk — you can learn more here: 👉 https://www.theericbermanteam.com/contact-us

Can pricing under market lead to multiple offers on Long Island?
In the right conditions, it can. Whether that applies depends on demand and competition — you can review that here: 👉 https://www.theericbermanteam.com/contact-us

How quickly will I know if my pricing strategy is working?
Early showing activity and feedback usually provide signals within the first few weeks. Interpreting those signs objectively can help — start here: 👉 https://www.theericbermanteam.com/contact-us

Should my pricing strategy change if market conditions shift after listing?
Yes. Markets evolve, and responsive pricing can protect momentum. Discussing adjustments early often leads to better outcomes — you can explore options here: 👉 https://www.theericbermanteam.com/contact-us

Eric Berman, REALTOR®
Compass Greater NY
917-225-8596
eric@ericbermanre.com

www.theericbermanteam.com

How Do I Decide Between Pricing Slightly Under Market Value Versus Pricing at the Top of the Range?